STOS Theatre Company’s Nativity! The Musical – 17 November 2026, Lyceum Theatre
Continuing STOS reputation for bringing top quality musical theatre to the people of South Yorkshire and well deserved to be sold out for it’s full run, Nativity! The Musical sparkles and shines and should not be missed by fans of the film, which in my opinion it out shines, and anyone who has ever watched a nativity play and wants to get into the festive spirit, guaranteeing you will have as much fun watching as the entire cast looking to have performing it.
Of course the real stars of the show are the children (split into two teams, we had Team Candy Canes) and like their film counterparts they brought their characters brilliantly to life capturing their emotions and attitudes and what it’s like to be from two very different schools and be treated very differently. It takes a lot of bravery, confidence, talent and stage presence to perform so successfully on such a big stage to so many people and each of them looked like they had done so their entire life (leaving my daughter jealous of their talent). They also brought all of the iconic moments of the film to life on stage with no obvious nerves from the auditions to the death slide from the top of the cathedral and the accidental costume change challenge on stage, which they pulled off without breaking a sweat. The musical numbers from the film are iconic to its fans and the children more than did them justice whilst also pulling at our heart strings with the emotion filled “Dear Father Christmas”. As a mum of a seven year old I am used to getting emotional seeing my daughter in her annual school nativity but with this production you grow to love each of the children and adults in the show so much over the course of the show that you get emotional by the time they perform theirs to.

However we can’t forget the adult leads, who all made their characters their own and were equally superb and supportive of their young co-stars, having to build that natural connection with not one but two teams of them. The lead teacher in all of Debbie Issit’s film series is always played by a famous British actor and Richard Granger’s performance as Paul Maddens thoroughly reminded me of Reece Shearsmith if he ever gets offered the lead in a future Nativity film. Paul goes on one of the biggest character journeys in the show with his relationship with his co-stars all changing and this felt thoroughly natural with us all joining him. Charlotte Waxman as Jennifer Lore provided the perfectly love interest, sharing natural chemistry with Paul and more than with any other cast member got to show that she would not be out of place as leading lady in any musical with her stunning rendition of “Jennifer’s Plea”.

Matt Bevan as Gordon Shakespeare seemed to delight in bringing his character and rivalry with St Bernadettes to life so much so that even if his character didn’t get the lead in it’s own production you’re sure he would still demand to do it. I must also mention Mark Harris as reviewer Patrick Burns, who may be a slight stereotype of the local press reviewer, giving us theatre reviewers a bad name, but popped up to read his own reviews with joyful self-glee and I’m sure would join us in giving this production five stars; and Josie Hackett as Mrs Bevan, who does not look old enough to play a retiring head teacher, but whose heartfelt speech a head of the nativity show all headteachers could learn from.
However the true star of the show has to be Sam Widdowson who somehow made the character of teaching assistant Mr Poppy even more iconic, making the character his own and using the role to showcase each of his comedic and entertainment talents to their very best and having delightful chemistry and connection with not only Paul Maddens but each and everyone of his child co-stars. From the moment he has his “Very First Day At School” you want him to be your own child’s classroom assistant (yes they might not get much work done but they would be loved, enjoy and be thoroughly supported in their school journey). Sam’s performance would be stand out in any production of the show and more than gives Marc Wootton’s film version a run for his money.

Director Keeley Kilby and assistant director James Bell got the very best out of a large cast and ensemble including the challenge of two shows within a show (no Gordon Shakespeare they have not changed the title of the show to Herod The Rock Opera), capturing the atmosphere of both schools, Hollywood and Coventry Cathedral. Like most school yard fights one of the stand out moments was how quickly the moment the fight breaks out between the two schools occurs whilst their direction of the journey through the various film studios will make you want to rewatch any classic Hollywood movie.
Choreographer Katie Granger and dance captain Ellie Hudson’s routines were fun and flawless and musical director Dominic Ridler again perfectly captured the styles and voices of each group of characters and with fun arrangements thoroughly complimented the original movie whilst adding classic festive favourites and new songs that would not be out of place in any musical.
Behind the scenes I must also mention JM Stage Visuals for their visual design, some of if not the best I have ever seen in a theatre show, really transplanting the audience into each scene and again a stand out as it transforms Paul Maddon and the audience straight into each film studio; wardrobe manager Christine Minott and her team for iconic Nativity costumes that looked straight from movie especially the stars and the Nazarene houses, Mr Poppy’s iconic jumpers and Jennifer’s dress during “Welcome To Hollywood” which looked like it had been borrowed by Katherine Jenkins; and a special mention to all the chaperones looking after a cast of 48 children across the run.
